American Idol has only been off our screens for about five minutes and it’s still been dominating the pop culture headlines all week!

After a lackluster season 12 which saw ratings plummet to an all time low, and a panel of judges no one liked, rumors recently surfaced that Idol is planning a very big step for its 13th year. All the current celebrity judges are out – and in their place will be a new panel comprising of FORMER Idol contestants.

The names currently being bandied around include Jennifer Hudson, Kelly Clarkson, Clay Aitken and Adam Lambert and yesterday reports surfaced that Hudson’s deal is essentially done. So is the story true? And is this a good move? Here’s my take…